50 Homes
Custer County, CO homes for sale with a Fireplace
In the last 30 days, Custer County home prices were up 28.5% compared to last year. The median price of a home was $482,000. View Custer County Market Insights
1 / 37
5 Days on Orchard
$495,000
LPT Realty • MLS 9299167 • Status: Active
1 / 50
$1,850,000
Southern Colorado Real Estate Brokers • MLS 2637102 • Status: Active
1 / 50
$1,300,000
eXp Realty, LLC • MLS 5578191 • Status: Active
1 / 50
$789,000
eXp Realty, LLC • MLS 9146960 • Status: Active
1 / 35
Price Drop
$465,000
$475,000
eXp Realty, LLC • MLS 6514617 • Status: Active
1 / 45
Price Drop
$539,000
$580,000
eXp Realty, LLC • MLS 3335932 • Status: Active
1 / 30
$334,000
eXp Realty, LLC • MLS 8925412 • Status: Active
1 / 49
Price Drop
$647,500
$650,000
eXp Realty, LLC • MLS 9835871 • Status: Active
1 / 43
Price Drop
$749,900
$769,900
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Rocky Mountain • MLS 4633695 • Status: Active
1 / 25
Price Drop
$349,000
$369,000
Keller Williams Performance Realty • MLS 1710061 • Status: Active
1 / 44
$2,200,000
Mattie Burtt Realty Inc • MLS 4658759 • Status: Active
1 / 38
Price Drop
$770,000
$775,000
Your Neighborhood Realty, Inc. • MLS 2774399 • Status: Active
1 / 47
Price Drop
$1,150,000
$1,250,000
Keller Williams Trilogy • MLS 7159695 • Status: Active
1 / 49
$1,210,000
Hayden Outdoors LLC • MLS 2092077 • Status: Active
1 / 29
$339,000
HomeSmart Preferred Realty • MLS 5109898 • Status: Active
1 / 20
$310,000
Reeves Real Estate • MLS 5401488 • Status: Active
1 / 50
$935,000
Ranger Real Estate, LLC • MLS 5578067 • Status: Active
1 / 34
Price Drop
$625,000
$635,000
Summit & Main Realty Group • MLS 7972993 • Status: Active
1 / 28
Price Drop
$925,000
$945,000
Your Neighborhood Realty Inc • MLS 1842069 • Status: Active
1 / 50
Price Drop
$595,900
$660,000
Mattie Burtt Realty Inc • MLS 2022852 • Status: Active
1 / 32
Price Drop
$365,000
$384,900
Southern Colorado Real Estate Brokers • MLS 2861974 • Status: Active
1 / 29
Price Drop
$685,000
$719,000
Exp Realty LLC • MLS 7129383 • Status: Active
1 / 36
$218,000
Watson Land Company • MLS 6692836 • Status: Active
1 / 50
Price Drop
$899,967
$930,000
Mossy Oak Properties / Mountain Ranch and Home Brokers • MLS 2207666 • Status: Active
1 / 38
$495,000
Watson Land Company • MLS 3629582 • Status: Active
1 / 36
Price Drop
$925,000
$950,000
Westcliffe Home & Ranch • MLS 7965955 • Status: Active
1 / 50
Price Drop
$599,900
$625,000
ERA Shields Real Estate • MLS 7932866 • Status: Active
1 / 36
$2,400,000
United Country Wapiti Ranch Realty and Auction LLC • MLS 9822019 • Status: Active
1 / 35
$799,000
Mountain Land Properties Llc • MLS 9127661 • Status: Active
1 / 31
$450,000
Keller Williams Clients Choice Realty • MLS 9317760 • Status: Active
1 / 34
Price Drop
$775,000
$799,000
Mountain Land Properties Llc • MLS 4121461 • Status: Active
1 / 50
$699,500
Hayden Outdoors LLC • MLS 4716376 • Status: Active
1 / 34
Price Drop
$1,075,000
$1,120,000
Keller Williams Clients Choice Realty • MLS 3571278 • Status: Active
1 / 50
$775,000
Hayden Outdoors LLC • MLS 8704257 • Status: Active
1 / 36
$885,000
Summit & Main Realty Group • MLS 6480286 • Status: Active
Viewing 1-36 of 50 homes
Custer County Market Trends
All Home Types
In the last 30 days, homes for sale in Custer County, CO sold for a median price of $482,000, up 28.5% compared to the same period last year. The median price per square foot was $286.90, up 5.1% year-over-year. There were 6 homes sold, down from 8 last year.
Median Sale Price
$482,000
+28.5% year-over-year
Median Price per Sq. Ft.
$286.90
+5.1% year-over-year
Number of Homes Sold
6
-25% year-over-year
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the median home sale price in Custer County, CO?
In the last 30 days, the median home sale price in Custer County was $482,000, up 28.5% compared to the same period last year. The "median" price is the middle price - half of the homes here were sold for less, the other half for more.
How many homes are for sale in Custer County, CO?
There were 159 homes for sale in Custer County as of September 10, 2025. There were 16 new listings within the last 30 days as well. The more homes on the market, the more choices buyers have.
How up-to-date are Orchard's new listings in Custer County, CO?
The new homes and houses for sale on Orchard's listings pages are updated hundreds of times each day, with listings in Custer County last seen updated at . New listings can appear every day, but many listings first appear on the market mid-week.
How much competition is there to buy a home in Custer County, CO?
In the last 30 days, the median number of days a home in Custer County remained on the market (DOM) was 14. In areas with a low DOM, homes are sold quickly and the competition is fierce; in areas with higher DOMs, you may have more options and more time to make an offer.
Home Buying Resources
View All Articles
The real estate listing information and related content displayed on this site is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information and related content is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Pikes Peak REALTOR® Services Corp.