1. Overview
  2. Location
  3. Interior
  4. Exterior
  5. Property
  6. Schools
  7. Similar
Listed by COLDWELL BANKER REALTY. Sold by PREFERRED REAL ESTATE BROKERS II
STELLAR logo

Listed by COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Status: Sold

1724 Cottonwood Creek Pl 
Lake Mary, FL 32746

Sold Price

$1,775,000

Sold on Jun 20, 2025
Two living spaces in one! Don’t miss out on this stunning, custom built 5 bedroom, 5 ½ bath home featuring a private guest suite with separate entrance - ideal for multi-generational living. Circular driveway leads guests into a dramatic entrance that features 12 ft. ceilings, travertine tile highlighted by hardwood flooring, freshly painted interior, plantation shutters, crown molding, and all surrounded by lush landscaping. Entertaining is a delight and cooks will enjoy the custom cabinets with display shelving, granite counters, huge island with prep sink, newer Bosch dishwasher, builtin SubZero fridge (2021), newer double oven, propane gas 5 burner cooktop featuring large vent to the outside, warming drawer, reverse osmosis drinking water, butler’s pantry and walk-in closet. Enjoy your morning expresso from the coffee bar in the primary retreat that also features a spa-like bath area with hidden walk- through shower, soaking tub, and dual vanities. On the other side of this extraordinary home is the family room with gas fireplace and wine bar, game room complete with pool table and bar, and the piece de resistance - a complete guest suite with private entrance leading to large living area, built in bookcase, galley kitchen with fridge, sink, microwave, dishwasher, granite counters, garages and one features space long enough for a 21 foot vehicle/boat. In all, 5 vehicles can be stored. Hobbyists will enjoy the five huge walk-in closet areas featured in one of the garages. There are two second floors in this home….one has the 6th bedroom and en-suite bath, a gym with some equipment and a theater room with surround sound, leather stadium seating for nine, beverage fridge, candy cabinet, popcorn machine, sink and loads of storage. The other second story the rooms are located from the kitchen and one is a storage area and the other is a fully A/Ced bonus room. Outdoor living is complete with saltwater pool/spa, propane grill, sink, beverage fridge and a new propane fireplace to warm the cooler months. Lovingly maintained some other "extras" are new pool filter and housing (2025), 10 new windows (2024), whole house gutters (2019), new rain sensor (2025), two water heaters and more. Located near all the city conveniences Magnolia Plantation is known for living in harmony with nature. Surrounded by the Wekiva forest, this community, with its wide streets and large lots, creates a magical feeling when entering. For recreation there is a park with a playground and covered pavilions, a sports area near the tennis courts with its own pavilion. This property may be under audio/visual surveillance.
Read more
Bedrooms
5
Baths
5.5
House Size
6,348 sqft
Year Built
2004
Lot Size
0.99 ac

Location

Curious what your home is worth?

Get the most accurate free home valuation in minutes

Get My Free Valuation
Orchard is 25% more accurate than the rest

Interior Information

appliances
Dishwasher
Disposal
Electric Water Heater
Microwave
Range
Range Hood
Refrigerator
cooling
Central Air
Zoned
features
Coffered Ceiling(s)
Crown Molding
Eat-in Kitchen
High Ceilings
Walk-in Closet(s)
fireplace
Family Room
Gas
Outside
flooring
Wood
heating
Central
Electric
Zoned
laundry features
Laundry Room
view
Trees/woods

Exterior Information

pool
Gunite
In Ground
Screen Enclosure
Private
road surface
Paved
roof
Tile

Property Information

community
Gated
Park
Playground
Sidewalks
Tennis Court(s)
Street Lights
construction
Block
foundation
Slab
hoa fees
$525.00
Quarterly
lot
Paved
other structures
Outdoor Kitchen
parking
Attached
security features
Gated Community
sewer
Public Sewer
subdivision name
Magnolia Plantation
utilities
Cable Available
Cable Connected
Electricity Connected
Propane
Water Connected
water source
Public
  • Listed By Margaret Summers
  • (407) 333-8088
  • COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
  • (407) 333-8088
  • robin.muzeka@floridamoves.com
  • MLS O6302356
  • Sold by Michael Mello, PA
  • PREFERRED REAL ESTATE BROKERS II
  • MLS 261211873

Curious what your home is worth?

Get the most accurate free home valuation in minutes

Get My Free Valuation
Orchard is 25% more accurate than the rest

Similar Homes

The stress-free way to buy and sell

When you work with an Orchard agent to find your next home, they can also help you sell your current home for market price, stress-free.

Learn More